← Teams

The Players Club 4

2026 FALL A18&O WEEKEND · FALL 18&O 3.0 WOMEN Career

23 players · average NTRP 2.88 / OHIO VALLEY

No matches recorded for this roster in this league — it may be a placeholder registration, or the season may not have started.

View scouting list →
Schedule17 played
2026-01-18vs Scarborough 1Lost 1–4
L#1 DoublesElizabeth Blount Mccormick / Jennifer McHale vs Stacy Chalmers / Carson Isaac3-6, 0-6
L#1 SinglesMarissa Fernandez vs Lisa Hartig2-6, 2-6
W#2 DoublesSally Saeger Stratton / Nicole Fernandez vs Kimberly Rung / Ashley Emmons6-2, 6-3
L#2 SinglesBeth Stutz vs Barbara Hathaway6-7, 6-7
L#3 DoublesCaitlin Vincent / Kirsten Sheely vs Joy Holley / Nicole Cordonnier2-6, 4-6
2026-01-11vs Scarborough 3Lost 2–3
L#1 DoublesAnjali Chavan / Jillian Roach vs Katelyn Whetsel / Molly McGuire4-6, 6-2, 0-1
W#1 SinglesCasey Russo vs AnnaMarie Cline6-4, 6-3
W#2 DoublesCara Grantier / Kerrigan McVicker vs Joy McArthur / Mackenzie Kesler6-4, 6-1
L#2 SinglesCaitlin Vincent vs Rommy Ulloa6-7, 6-7
L#3 DoublesNanette Lacuesta-Kimmel / Nicole Fernandez vs Deb Clay / Elvira Ordillas3-6, 7-5, 0-1
2026-01-04vs Racquet Club 1Won 4–1
W#1 DoublesElizabeth Blount Mccormick / Alison Staloch vs Karla Crucke / Sarah Squillante6-2, 6-3
W#1 SinglesJen Mascho vs Lena Furci6-3, 6-3
L#2 DoublesAimee DeLuca / Jillian Roach vs Stephanie Bisca / Lori Yang3-6, 6-4, 0-1
W#2 SinglesSally Saeger Stratton vs Tracy Steinbrenner6-4, 6-4
W#3 DoublesMarissa Fernandez / Jessica Werner vs Megan Roberts / Mitzi Moshiri6-4, 6-4
2025-12-21vs Olympic 1Won 4–0
W#1 DoublesJillian Roach / Alison Staloch vs Lara Blumberg / Karen Deveny6-1, 2-6, 1-0
W#1 SinglesMarissa Fernandez vs Abigail Shaw6-3, 6-3
W#2 DoublesSusan Chieffo / Jennifer McHale vs Lisa Jolley / Whitney Purdum6-1, 6-3
W#3 DoublesJessica Werner / Nanette Lacuesta-Kimmel vs Lori Finefrock / Karen Vaughn5-7, 6-1, 1-0
2025-12-14vs Racquet Club 2Won 3–2
W#1 DoublesAnjali Chavan / Jillian Roach vs Abby Zimmerman / Marlene Eymann4-6, 6-5, 1-0
W#1 SinglesSusan Chieffo vs Brooke Green7-5, 7-5
L#2 DoublesAimee DeLuca / Nicole Fernandez vs Sally Briggs / Christy Bauer4-6, 5-7
L#2 SinglesJessica Werner vs Leigh Temsey2-6, 2-6
W#3 DoublesCaitlin Vincent / Nanette Lacuesta-Kimmel vs Abby Cover / Julie Harvey6-1, 6-4
2025-12-07vs Racquet Club 3Won 3–2
L#1 DoublesSusan Chieffo / Kirsten Sheely vs Marisa Nye / Natalie Musser4-6, 2-6
W#1 SinglesJen Mascho vs Daven Holmquist6-3, 6-3
W#2 DoublesMarissa Fernandez / Sally Saeger Stratton vs Heather Harcourt / Lori Hall7-5, 6-5
L#2 SinglesAimee DeLuca vs Jennifer Berg3-6, 3-6
W#3 DoublesNanette Lacuesta-Kimmel / Casey Russo vs Anne Finley / Kerry Ruberg6-1, 6-2
2025-11-23vs New GenWon 3–1
L#1 DoublesJennifer McHale / Nicole Fernandez vs Chelsea Hillenburg / Qing Radebaugh3-6, 4-6
W#1 SinglesJen Mascho vs Emi Sauer7-6, 7-6
W#2 DoublesCasey Russo / Cara Grantier vs Nutan Ruegsegger / Heidi Jensen6-3, 2-6, 1-0
W#3 DoublesCaitlin Vincent / Maybelle Ball vs Stephani Kim / Lucy DeGuzman2-6, 6-4, 1-0
2025-11-17vs Elysium 1Lost 2–3
L#1 DoublesJen Mascho / Kerrigan McVicker vs Vicki Prescott / Darcie Schalk3-6, 1-6
W#1 SinglesMarissa Fernandez vs Amy Brearley7-5, 7-5
L#2 DoublesCasey Russo / Susan Chieffo vs Kelly Syroka / K'Anne Cox1-6, 1-6
W#2 SinglesCara Grantier vs Jill Cullinan6-2, 6-2
L#3 DoublesCaitlin Vincent / Karina Gomez vs Lori Henry / Kelly Ackert2-6, 2-6
2025-11-09vs The Players Club 2Lost 0–5
L#1 DoublesCasey Russo / Anjali Chavan vs Jacqueline Guagenti / Yasuko Kato2-6, 2-6
L#1 SinglesJen Mascho vs Heidi Miller2-6, 2-6
L#2 DoublesMarissa Fernandez / Beth Stutz vs Donya Wilson / Megan Stout0-6, 2-6
L#2 SinglesKerrigan McVicker vs Kelsey Perkins6-7, 6-7
L#3 DoublesNicole Fernandez / Caitlin Vincent vs Gloria McColgan / Erin Sexton3-6, 3-6
2025-11-02vs Elysium 2Split 2–2
L#1 DoublesCasey Russo / Kerrigan McVicker vs Megan Cooper / Sunanda Sahlin4-6, 6-5, 1-0
L#2 DoublesJenny Reed / Natalie Payne vs Gianna Garnett / DeAnna Sullivan7-5, 3-6, 1-0
W#2 SinglesBeth Stutz vs Laura Factor6-2, 6-3
W#3 DoublesCara Grantier / Susan Chieffo vs Suzanne Smith / Carrie Gray6-4, 7-6
2025-10-26vs The Players Club 1Lost 1–4
L#1 DoublesNicole Fernandez / Jillian Roach vs Elisa DiMeo / Elizabeth Patterson2-6, 2-6
W#1 SinglesJen Mascho vs Sarah Ortlieb6-4, 6-4
L#2 DoublesAimee DeLuca / Caitlin Vincent vs Sarah Miller / Allison Quick1-6, 1-6
L#2 SinglesMarissa Fernandez vs Jill Hawley2-6, 3-6
L#3 DoublesAudrey Varwig / Maybelle Ball vs Nikki Miller / Andreanna Hsieh4-6, 2-6
2025-10-19vs Wickertree 1Won 3–2
W#1 DoublesAnjali Chavan / Aimee DeLuca vs Kelly Bannen / Tanya Bomsta6-2, 7-6
L#1 SinglesCasey Russo vs Colleen Mar6-7, 6-7
W#2 DoublesSally Saeger Stratton / Elizabeth Blount Mccormick vs Marisa Ratajczak / Angela Caffaratti6-0, 6-2
L#2 SinglesAudrey Varwig vs Demicha Rankin3-6, 3-6
W#3 DoublesSusan Chieffo / Nanette Lacuesta-Kimmel vs Tricia Segnini / Lauren Green6-2, 7-6
2025-10-12vs Scarborough 2Won 3–1
W#1 DoublesAnne Shukwit / Kirsten Sheely vs Michelle Goodman / Laura Ryzenman1-6, 6-2, 1-0
W#2 DoublesCara Grantier / Kerrigan McVicker vs Mina Khorrami / Wendy Blanco6-2, 3-6, 1-0
L#2 SinglesSusan Chieffo vs Loni Arrese3-6, 4-6
W#3 DoublesAudrey Varwig / Jennifer McHale vs Pam Gurwin / Veronica Schuetz7-5, 4-2
2025-09-28vs The Players Club 3Won 3–2
W#1 DoublesJenny Reed / Natalie Payne vs Jesseca Middleton / Erin Daly3-6, 6-3, 1-0
L#1 SinglesJen Mascho vs Ann Miksza6-7, 6-7
W#2 DoublesJillian Roach / Jennifer McHale vs Ali Oliver / Daryl Cottrell6-0, 6-4
L#2 SinglesKirsten Sheely vs Mary Zelasko3-6, 3-6
W#3 DoublesCasey Russo / Beth Stutz vs Jennifer Hobrecht / Mary Ernst Mccolgan6-3, 2-6, 1-0
2025-09-21vs Olympic 2Won 4–1
W#1 DoublesAnne Shukwit / Alison Staloch vs Gemma Park / Cassie Dickerson6-0, 6-1
W#1 SinglesJen Mascho vs Emily Nichols7-6, 7-6
W#2 DoublesAnjali Chavan / Jillian Roach vs DeAnna Duvall / Jennifer Adornetto7-5, 6-3
W#2 SinglesJennifer McHale vs Melissa Barnett6-3, 6-3
L#3 DoublesSusan Chieffo / Audrey Varwig vs Nilu Ekanayake / Beth Gilbert3-6, 3-6
2025-09-14vs Wickertree 3Lost 1–4
L#1 DoublesCasey Russo / Aimee DeLuca vs Ashley Graber / Melissa Soderberg2-6, 3-6
L#1 SinglesJenny Reed vs Heather Goettee6-7, 6-7
L#2 DoublesNicole Fernandez / Marissa Fernandez vs Sara Bode / Cindy Nicolette2-6, 4-6
W#2 SinglesCara Grantier vs Melia Rose6-2, 6-2
L#3 DoublesMaybelle Ball / Caitlin Vincent vs Sarah Edwards / SueAnn Hufford4-6, 1-6
2025-09-07vs Wickertree 2Lost 2–3
L#1 DoublesAlison Staloch / Anjali Chavan vs Jenni Kneuertz / Jaimee Hoy6-2, 0-6, 0-1
W#1 SinglesAnne Shukwit vs Kerry Prokop6-4, 6-4
L#2 DoublesCasey Russo / Susan Chieffo vs Jennifer Sugerik / Katie Carter2-6, 2-6
W#2 SinglesMarissa Fernandez vs Deidra Kellogg-Okoye6-2, 6-3
L#3 DoublesNicole Fernandez / Sally Saeger Stratton vs Katie Beal / Susan Parsons4-6, 5-7
A tie can be incomplete. Tell us if someone is missing.
i
Grouped by tie — one fixture, several lines. A line shows only when a player on it is someone we have indexed, so an early-season tie for a newly-added team can look short. This also means the line count here will not match the header, which counts individual player appearances.
Flight standings3 teams · FALL 18&O 3.0 WOMEN Career
TeamWLInd. WInd. LSets lostGames lost
1The Players Club 498434293808
2The Players Club 3893550103763
3Racquet Club 34133352109824

Ordered by team wins, then losses, then sets lost — the order USTA uses to seed a flight. Individual wins are lines, not ties.

See the full flight, with every team’s record

ScoutingWhere each opponent usually plays

Signed-in extra: whether this captain plays strict strength order or mixes it up, from every doubles line they have put out. Create a free account to see it.

Roster averages 2.71 estimated across 22 rated players. No lineup is published in advance, so the column below is where each player has actually been used — a captain's habits are the best available forecast. Sign in and claim your record to see who you have played.

3.06
Alison Staloch
usually #1 Doubles 100% · published 3
3.00
Anne Shukwit
usually #1 Doubles 67%, also #1 Singles 33% · published 3
2.97
Jenny Reed
usually #1 Doubles 33%, also #2 Doubles 33% · published —
2.94
Jen Mascho
usually #1 Singles 88%, also #1 Doubles 13% · published —
2.84
Sally Saeger Stratton
usually #2 Doubles 60%, also #2 Singles 20% · published —
2.83
Aimee DeLuca
usually #2 Doubles 50%, also #1 Doubles 33% · published 3
2.75
Nanette Lacuesta-Kimmel
usually #3 Doubles 100% · published —
2.74
Jennifer McHale
usually #2 Doubles 33%, also #1 Doubles 33% · published —
2.74
Jillian Roach
usually #1 Doubles 57%, also #2 Doubles 43% · published —
2.74
Natalie Payne
usually #1 Doubles 50%, also #2 Doubles 50% · published —
2.73
Casey Russo
usually #2 Doubles 30%, also #1 Doubles 30% · published 3
2.73
Cara Grantier
usually #1 Singles 57%, also #2 Doubles 21% · published 3
2.72
Kerrigan McVicker
usually #2 Doubles 40%, also #1 Doubles 40% · published —
2.70
Kirsten Sheely
usually #1 Doubles 50%, also #2 Singles 25% · published —
2.70
Marissa Fernandez
usually #1 Singles 33%, also #2 Doubles 33% · published —
2.69
Jessica Werner
usually #3 Doubles 67%, also #2 Singles 33% · published —
2.67
Susan Chieffo
usually #2 Doubles 33%, also #3 Doubles 33% · published —
2.62
Audrey Varwig
usually #1 Doubles 46%, also #3 Doubles 23% · published 3
2.46
Karina Gomez
usually #2 Doubles 40%, also #3 Doubles 40% · published —
2.44
Caitlin Vincent
usually #3 Doubles 75%, also #2 Singles 13% · published 2.5
2.37
Beth Stutz
usually #2 Singles 50%, also #3 Doubles 25% · published 2.5
2.29
Maybelle Ball
usually #2 Doubles 43%, also #3 Doubles 43% · published —
—
Patricia Gray
published —
Established pairs

Doubles pairs from this roster with three or more matches together anywhere — ordered by performance against what the rating gap predicted, not by record.

Casey Russo + Nanette Lacuesta-Kimmel5–457% games+9.3% vs expected
Kerrigan McVicker + Jillian Roach4–162% games+6.5% vs expected
Susan Chieffo + Nanette Lacuesta-Kimmel4–652% games+5.9% vs expected
Maybelle Ball + Caitlin Vincent3–339% games−1.7% vs expected
Casey Russo + Susan Chieffo2–636% games−9.3% vs expected
Susan Chieffo + Anne Shukwit3–358% gamesnot enough data
Alison Staloch + Jenny Reed4–155% gamesnot enough data
Casey Russo + Aimee DeLuca0–538% gamesnot enough data
Roster

Ordered by our estimated dynamic rating, which is why two players at the same published level are not tied — a published 4.0 says nothing about where inside the band someone sits. Lines played in this team’s season are shown beside each name.

3
Alison Staloch
31W–11L career · 4 lines in 2026
<1%31%69%
3.06
3
Anne Shukwit
23W–16L career · 3 lines in 2026
<1%51%49%
3.00
—
Jenny Reed
29W–42L career · 3 lines in 2026
<1%59%41%
2.97
—
Jen Mascho
42W–33L career · 8 lines in 2026
<1%68%32%
2.94
—
Sally Saeger Stratton
18W–14L career · 5 lines in 2026
<1%88%11%
2.84
3
Aimee DeLuca
38W–43L career · 6 lines in 2026
1%90%9%
2.83
—
Nanette Lacuesta-Kimmel
33W–49L career · 5 lines in 2026
2%95%3%
2.75
—
Jennifer McHale
19W–29L career · 6 lines in 2026
3%95%2%
2.74
—
Jillian Roach
22W–29L career · 7 lines in 2026
3%95%2%
2.74
—
Natalie Payne
12W–10L career · 2 lines in 2026
3%94%2%
2.74
3
Casey Russo
55W–83L career · 10 lines in 2026
4%94%2%
2.73
3
Cara Grantier
39W–26L career · 14 lines in 2026
4%94%2%
2.73
—
Kerrigan McVicker
11W–9L career · 5 lines in 2026
4%94%2%
2.72
—
Kirsten Sheely
26W–32L career · 4 lines in 2026
6%93%1%
2.70
—
Marissa Fernandez
30W–31L career · 9 lines in 2026
7%92%1%
2.70
—
Jessica Werner
24W–38L career · 3 lines in 2026
7%92%1%
2.69
—
Susan Chieffo
40W–50L career · 8 lines in 2026
9%90%1%
2.67
3
Audrey Varwig
19W–22L career · 13 lines in 2026
19%81%<1%
2.62
—
Karina Gomez
10W–29L career · 5 lines in 2026
0%64%36%
2.46
2.5
Caitlin Vincent
17W–46L career · 8 lines in 2026
0%69%31%
2.44
2.5
Beth Stutz
11W–26L career · 4 lines in 2026
0%85%15%
2.37
—
Maybelle Ball
19W–34L career · 7 lines in 2026
0%94%6%
2.29
—
Patricia Gray
17W–26L career · no lines in 2026
not enough data
—

Three percentages are where each player stands right now: the chance they are below their band, inside it, or above it, on the way they are playing this season. The number on the right is our estimated dynamic rating, which USTA never publishes. This is today rather than a forecast of December, because a forecast has to assume future matches and cannot know whether someone will even be offered them. Percentages are blank where a player has too few matches this season, or at a level where the model does not yet beat a base-rate guess; the estimate is a weaker claim than a probability and survives where those do not.

Not affiliated with or endorsed by the USTA. Ratings labelled as published are USTA year-end figures; anything we describe as an estimate is ours, not USTA’s. Match data is from USTA TennisLink.