Teams

ACC/McCabe/Godfrey

2026 COTA USTA Adult 40 & Over Men - Thursday - Fall '25 · Men 3.5

16 players · average NTRP 3.42 / GEORGIA

No matches recorded for this roster in this league — it may be a placeholder registration, or the season may not have started.

View scouting list →
Schedule6 played
2025-10-23vs COTA/Bradley FortnerLost 05
L#1 DoublesGary Avants / Michael Crain vs Lance Herndon / Bobby Holton1-6, 1-6
L#1 SinglesMichael Broun vs Wes Ivester4-6, 1-6
L#2 DoublesTimothy McCabe / Peter Rutledge vs Christopher Strother / Michael Pickern2-6, 1-6
L#3 DoublesJames Chin / Gary Gerrard vs Nicolas Cervini / Derek Dalonzo1-6, 0-6
L#4 DoublesJay Sampson / Leslie McCrary vs Matt Stancel / Matt Anders3-6, 6-1, 0-1
2025-10-16vs TGC/GarrettWon 41
L#1 DoublesLeslie McCrary / Adam West vs Mike Phillips / Kevin Kummerer6-1, 5-7, 0-1
W#1 SinglesMichael Broun vs Donald Garrett7-5, 6-3
W#2 DoublesJames Chin / Gary Gerrard vs Edward Klassen / Michael Morris7-6, 6-2
W#3 DoublesTimothy McCabe / Matt Steele vs Doug Cathey / Robert Carter6-3, 6-3
W#4 DoublesRyan Dietz / Andrew Herrin vs Lawrence Preston / Brian Forrester6-4, 6-2
2025-10-02vs OVP/Barnhart/BarrWon 40
W#1 DoublesPeter Rutledge / Adam West vs Steve Benefield / John Geib7-5, 5-7, 1-0
W#1 SinglesMichael Broun vs Mike Barr6-4, 4-6, 1-0
W#2 DoublesGary Avants / Chris Godfrey vs David Barnhart / Wes Peyton6-4, 6-0
W#3 DoublesJames Chin / Ryan Dietz vs Stuart Emerson / Ronald Rice6-0, 4-6, 1-0
2025-10-01vs COTA/Bradley FortnerLost 23
L#1 DoublesAdam West / Peter Rutledge vs Wes Ivester / Bobby Holton2-6, 6-7
L#1 SinglesMichael Broun vs Nicolas Cervini0-6, 3-6
L#2 DoublesJames Chin / Jay Sampson vs Michael Pickern / Christopher Strother2-6, 0-6
W#3 DoublesGary Gerrard / Chris Godfrey vs Matt Stancel / Kress Shook4-6, 6-4, 1-0
W#4 DoublesGary Avants / Michael Crain vs Bradley Fortner / Thierry Pagnier3-6, 6-2, 1-0
2025-09-11vs TGC/GarrettWon 32
W#1 DoublesAdam West / Gary Gerrard vs Garth Brandwein / Kevin Kummerer6-4, 7-5
L#1 SinglesMichael Broun vs Joe McVay2-6, 2-6
W#2 DoublesGary Avants / Timothy McCabe vs Juan Calvo / Marc McMain5-7, 6-4, 1-0
W#3 DoublesMichael Crain / Matt Steele vs Mike Phillips / Donald Garrett6-0, 6-3
L#4 DoublesRyan Dietz / Jay Sampson vs Brian Forrester / Joseph Smith6-3, 6-7, 0-1
2025-09-03vs OVP/Barnhart/BarrWon 41
W#1 DoublesPeter Rutledge / Adam West vs Mike Barr / Quint Newcomer6-3, 3-6, 1-0
W#1 SinglesMichael Broun vs Stuart Emerson6-3, 6-3
L#2 DoublesTimothy McCabe / Andrew Herrin vs Ron Braxley / Wes Peyton4-6, 3-6
W#3 DoublesJames Chin / Matt Steele vs Ronald Rice / Steve Benefield6-2, 6-3
W#4 DoublesRyan Dietz / Jay Sampson vs William Culpepper / Wendell Beard6-4, 3-6, 1-0
A tie can be incomplete. Tell us if someone is missing.
i
Grouped by tie — one fixture, several lines. A line shows only when a player on it is someone we have indexed, so an early-season tie for a newly-added team can look short. This also means the line count here will not match the header, which counts individual player appearances.

Flight standings for Men 3.5 have not been collected yet. Where we have them we show every team in the flight ranked, with this team highlighted. The crawler is still filling in older seasons and flights.

ScoutingWhere each opponent usually plays

Signed-in extra: whether this captain plays strict strength order or mixes it up, from every doubles line they have put out. Create a free account to see it.

Roster averages 3.16 estimated across 14 rated players. No lineup is published in advance, so the column below is where each player has actually been used — a captain's habits are the best available forecast. Sign in and claim your record to see who you have played.

3.75
Andrew Herrin
usually #2 Doubles 50%, also #4 Doubles 50% · published 3.5
3.32
Chris Godfrey
usually #3 Doubles 50%, also #2 Doubles 50% · published 3.5
3.29
Adam West
usually #1 Doubles 100% · published 3.5
3.28
Michael Broun
usually #1 Singles 100% · published
3.24
Peter Rutledge
usually #1 Doubles 75%, also #2 Doubles 25% · published
3.18
Gary Avants
usually #2 Doubles 50%, also #4 Doubles 25% · published 3.5
3.15
Michael Crain
usually #4 Doubles 33%, also #1 Doubles 33% · published
3.10
Leslie McCrary
usually #4 Doubles 50%, also #1 Doubles 50% · published
3.04
Gary Gerrard
usually #3 Doubles 50%, also #1 Doubles 25% · published 3.5
3.03
Ryan Dietz
usually #4 Doubles 75%, also #3 Doubles 25% · published
3.02
James Chin
usually #3 Doubles 60%, also #2 Doubles 40% · published 3
2.99
Timothy McCabe
usually #2 Doubles 75%, also #3 Doubles 25% · published
2.99
Jay Sampson
usually #4 Doubles 75%, also #2 Doubles 25% · published
2.90
William Quinn
published
Robert Brutz
published
W Thomas McNicholas
published
Established pairs

Doubles pairs from this roster with three or more matches together anywhere — ordered by performance against what the rating gap predicted, not by record.

Timothy McCabe + Chris Godfrey2350% games+1.6% vs expected
Ryan Dietz + Jay Sampson1439% gamesnot enough data
Timothy McCabe + Peter Rutledge224 matchesnot enough data
Peter Rutledge + Adam West314 matchesnot enough data
Michael Broun + Adam West044 matchesnot enough data
Gary Avants + Adam West033 matchesnot enough data
Gary Gerrard + James Chin123 matchesnot enough data
W Thomas McNicholas + Chris Godfrey033 matchesnot enough data
Roster

Ordered by our estimated dynamic rating, which is why two players at the same published level are not tied — a published 4.0 says nothing about where inside the band someone sits. Lines played in this team’s season are shown beside each name.

3.5
Andrew Herrin
3W–4L career · type S · 2 lines in 2026
<1%3%97%
3.75
3.5
Chris Godfrey
23W–26L career · 2 lines in 2026
1%91%8%
3.32
3.5
Adam West
11W–16L career · 5 lines in 2026
1%93%5%
3.29
Michael Broun
10W–21L career · 6 lines in 2026
2%94%4%
3.28
Peter Rutledge
7W–6L career · 4 lines in 2026
3%95%2%
3.24
3.5
Gary Avants
17W–24L career · 4 lines in 2026
8%91%1%
3.18
Michael Crain
7W–5L career · 3 lines in 2026
12%87%<1%
3.15
Leslie McCrary
1W–6L career · 2 lines in 2026
23%77%<1%
3.10
3.5
Gary Gerrard
4W–5L career · 4 lines in 2026
39%61%<1%
3.04
Ryan Dietz
6W–11L career · 4 lines in 2026
41%59%<1%
3.03
3
James Chin
9W–14L career · 5 lines in 2026
<1%44%56%
3.02
Timothy McCabe
11W–18L career · 4 lines in 2026
52%48%<1%
2.99
Jay Sampson
3W–11L career · 4 lines in 2026
54%46%<1%
2.99
William Quinn
0W–6L career · no lines in 2026
78%22%<1%
2.90
Robert Brutz
6W–7L career · no lines in 2026
not enough data
W Thomas McNicholas
5W–10L career · no lines in 2026
not enough data

Three percentages are where each player stands right now: the chance they are below their band, inside it, or above it, on the way they are playing this season. The number on the right is our estimated dynamic rating, which USTA never publishes. This is today rather than a forecast of December, because a forecast has to assume future matches and cannot know whether someone will even be offered them. Percentages are blank where a player has too few matches this season, or at a level where the model does not yet beat a base-rate guess; the estimate is a weaker claim than a probability and survives where those do not.

Not affiliated with or endorsed by the USTA. Ratings labelled as published are USTA year-end figures; anything we describe as an estimate is ours, not USTA’s. Match data is from USTA TennisLink.